Tuesday, October 2, 2018

Rivers West – Louis L'Amour, 1975 ★½

Throwing in the Towel, or Something

Rivers West is what happens when an author loses interest in a novel halfway into writing it. The craziest part is I can’t understand why, as this atypical offering from western-fiction legend Louis L’Amour opens with much promise.

It’s 1821, and young Quebecer Jean Talon is negotiating a swampy path for what he hears are fresh boat-building opportunities along the great rivers of the American West.

Suddenly a ghostly hand rises from behind a log. It belongs a British officer, stabbed fatally in the lung. He tells Jean of a very bad man, “a renegade, a traitor.” Before Jean can make up his mind about much of anything, events conspire to plunge him into the heart of the plot.

Saturday, September 29, 2018

Ghosts – Henrik Ibsen, 1881 ★★

Something Rotten in Norway

A sensation when it first hit the stage, Ibsen’s Ghosts is hard to enjoy now. You see how the play pushed boundaries in the 19th century, giving voice to forbidden ideas; today it feels melodramatic and forced – a four-hankie weeper about a tortured artist and his ever-faithful mother stuck together in the repressive backwaters of western Norway.

There’s even a light-comic rustic and a self-righteous parson on hand to lend a Wuthering Heights flavor. Regardless of its creakiness, Ghosts has relevance. It did make Ibsen an even bigger name in his own time, and remains as well-known as all but a handful of his plays.

Wednesday, September 26, 2018

The Broken Ear – Hergé, 1935-37 [Revised 1943] ★★★½

Thrills and Giggles in South America

Street fights. Car crashes. Terrorism. Violent government overthrows. Murder by gas. Murder by drowning. Death by bomb. Devils escorting doomed souls into hell.

Is this a children’s comic book, or a Mickey Spillane novel?

Sunday, September 23, 2018

The Ninth Juror – Giraud Chester, 1970 ★★★

Secrets of a Jury Room

If you have seen 12 Angry Men, you may remember the line: “No jury can declare a man guilty unless it’s sure.” But how practical an approach is that, really? How sure is sure?

Going by that play/movie, “sure” is well-nigh impossible if you can’t be sure a witness isn’t lying for attention or a defense lawyer is up to snuff. If we all followed that pious Henry Fonda formula, prisons would be full of bankers and not much else.

The real world offers better examples of justice in action, like this long-forgotten book by a TV executive.

Saturday, September 22, 2018

The Three Musketeers – Alexandre Dumas, 1844 ★★★½

A Potboiler for the Ages

The test of a great storyteller lies not in the story, but the telling. Few storytellers stand the test of time like Alexandre Dumas in his breakout novel The Three Musketeers.

Is it a great story? I don’t think so. The narrative ambles about, plays up many tropes of the historical-adventure genre, takes several protracted detours, and doesn’t quite climax after 600 pages as much as run out of steam. But what a ride!

Thursday, September 6, 2018

The Diamond Smugglers – Ian Fleming, 1957 ★½

A Bond Story that Never Was

You know their names, no introductions necessary: Ernst Stavro Blofeld. Goldfinger. Dr. No. Rosa Klebb. Classic villains brought to you by the same man who created their common foil, James Bond 007: Ian Fleming.

But none got the build-up of a villain from another Fleming book: Monsieur Diamant, a. k. a. Mr. Diamond.

As another vividly-named character in the same book, one “John Blaize,” explains it:

“You’ve written about some pretty good villains in your books, but truth is stranger, etc., and none of your villains stands up to Monsieur Diamant. I should say he’s the biggest crook in Europe, if not in the world – not only big, but completely successful.”

Monday, September 3, 2018

The City – Dean Koontz, 2014 ★½

Trying to Like Dean Koontz

Reading The City makes me wonder what makes for pop-fiction success. Is it writing something that truly engages, provokes, inspires? Or is it delivering product to a well-conditioned audience? 

After a pulsating start, The City settles into a tired-feeling, slow-moving tale that delivers morals and thrills with the loping subtlety of a ball-peen hammer.