Showing posts with label French history. Show all posts
Showing posts with label French history. Show all posts

Sunday, November 5, 2023

The Battle For Gaul – Julius Caesar, 58-50 B. C. ★★★½ [1980 Translation by Anne & Peter Wiseman]

Sic Transit Gloria Mundi

How often do you think of the Roman Empire? It’s not just a question; these days it’s a meme, mocking dreamers in no hurry to grow up. Imagining a world brought into clearer order is tempting. Reading about it as it happens can satisfy the hopelessly boyish at heart.

Julius Caesar had no such agenda when writing these episodic narratives of his conquests across France and parts beyond. His objective was political. Romans had long suffered from barbarian attacks. Now Caesar was doing something about it, at a time when his main rival Pompey enjoyed a 20-year head start conquering the rest of the known world.

Caesar sought glory and dictatorship. What he achieved instead was a work of history that would endure in Western culture long after the empire he helped to build had collapsed into ruins and darkness.

Sunday, July 24, 2022

Das Reich – Max Hastings, 1981 ★★½

Evil Taken Too Far

Can the end justify the means even when those means are wholly evil? Leaving aside moral, philosophical, and theological quibbles, can one look at wholesale murder from the perspective of getting something done and call it wrong simply on the basis of logic?

Yes, you can. Take the actions of a German SS armored division who, in order to cow rebellious French civilians en route to Normandy in June 1944, committed two massacres and numerous atrocities to gain a clear road to the front line.

This they did, proving in an immediate way the efficacy of terror as a tool of war, but also the limitations of same, for reasons explained by Max Hastings in this 1981 account of the division’s bloody march.

Saturday, October 2, 2021

The Day Of The Jackal – Frederick Forsyth, 1971 ★★★★★

Making a Tutorial out of a Debut

Genre fiction is easy to take for granted; when you pick up a thriller or a spy novel, you expect a certain kind of experience. It’s not about becoming a better person or learning something; it’s about satisfaction.

But when a novel delivers consistently in just about every facet: suspense, structure, logic, atmosphere, climax; and does so in a way that elevates the form, you need to take a step back and ask: How did he do it?

At least that’s what I do every time I finish reading this masterpiece.

Friday, July 2, 2021

A Distant Mirror: The Calamitous 14th Century – Barbara Tuchman, 1978 ★½

All Pain, No Gain

War, plague, poverty, religious doubt, the rich being totally evil and getting away with it… If you think this century has it bad, just imagine all that in the 1300s. Barbara Tuchman takes us through the ordeal of life in Europe just before the Renaissance; the result is pretty painful.

Also messy, confusing, and not at all fun to read. In fact, this is Tuchman at her toughest and most pedantic, a book lacking a thesis or character to latch onto.

Tuchman offers snark instead, lots of it: “If the fiction of chivalry molded outward behavior to some extent, it did not, any more than other models that man has made for himself, transform human nature.”

Friday, May 22, 2020

Champlain's Dream – David Hackett Fischer, 2008 ★★

Bouquet for a New World Man

Say what you will of the human condition, but biographies are often more fun, and usually more readable, when written with an ax to grind.

David Hackett Fischer, a marvelous writer and a great historian, takes one of America’s most likable explorers and spends over 600 pages explaining just how magnificent Samuel de Champlain was. The result is sprawling, convincing, and dull.

Monday, February 3, 2020

The Proud Tower – Barbara Tuchman, 1966 ★★

Arranging the Deck Chairs

Did the assassination of Archduke Franz Ferdinand cause World War I? Was it rather another assassination which took place hours before the war began, that of French socialist Jean Jaurès?

Or perhaps one too many feisty tone poems by Richard Strauss?

Maybe if the post-Victorian British weren’t so snooty and class-conscious, or the Americans had just heeded their anti-imperialist Speaker of the House, circumstances would have been different and mankind would have avoided one of its greatest calamities. Somehow.

Wednesday, March 6, 2019

The Guns Of August – Barbara Tuchman, 1962 ★★★½

The Best-Laid Plans

Barbara Tuchman didn’t quite catapult history books into events, but she moved that ball forward in a big way. For several decades her heavy tomes about medieval warfare and Chinese diplomacy were best-sellers people lugged to the beach.

None had the impact of The Guns Of August, her 1962 account of the first month of World War I. It won the next year’s non-fiction Pulitzer and achieved legend status during the Cuban Missile Crisis. President Kennedy was said to quote from it often, tasking staff to read it as war with Russia loomed.

Saturday, September 22, 2018

The Three Musketeers – Alexandre Dumas, 1844 ★★★½

A Potboiler for the Ages

The test of a great storyteller lies not in the story, but the telling. Few storytellers stand the test of time like Alexandre Dumas in his breakout novel The Three Musketeers.

Is it a great story? I don’t think so. The narrative ambles about, plays up many tropes of the historical-adventure genre, takes several protracted detours, and doesn’t quite climax after 600 pages as much as run out of steam. But what a ride!

Wednesday, September 27, 2017

The Great Cat Massacre And Other Episodes In French Cultural History – Robert Darnton, 1984 ★★

How the Past is a Foreign Country

As a product of the 20th century who finds himself deep into the 21st, I know a little about temporal dislocation. Whether it’s the politics, the music, or adjusting to casual swearing, mobile texting, or calorie-count signs at McDonalds, it’s like my head is in then; my body in now.

Imagine trying to make sense of a time that exists entirely outside living memory. This is the challenge Robert Darnton takes on in this collection of historical-anthropological essays looking back at 18th century France.

Darnton employs everything from Mother Goose to Jean-Jacques Rousseau to examine what constitutes the past, beyond chronology itself. His conclusion centers on different people who carried with them unfathomably different mindsets, or as he calls them, mentalitiés.