Anton Chekhov did comedy like Al Capone did Valentine’s Day.
Further proof of this comes in the form of The Cherry Orchard, a play so non-comedic it was advertised as a tragedy in its Moscow debut, causing the author to blow up.
Seeing death, destruction, and despair aplenty, the director, legendary acting instructor Konstantin Stanislavski, knew it was beyond even his powers to get his cast to play funny. “But Anton Pavlovich, you have them crying many times in the stage directions,” he pointed out.
Chekhov disagreed vehemently, declaring his play “happy” and ruined by the premiere’s tragic approach. Shortly after, Chekhov died at the age of 44. It was one way to end a debate, though I think the play’s performance history reflects Stanislavski’s view. The play may still be called a “comedy,” but most people know it’s not.

