Showing posts with label PD James. Show all posts
Showing posts with label PD James. Show all posts

Saturday, October 31, 2020

A Taste For Death – P. D. James, 1986 ★½

Too Many Notes

Reading this brought to mind a line in that great Mozart movie Amadeus, when Wolfgang asks the Habsburg court why their emperor doesn’t like his latest piece. One courtier answers: “Too many notes.”

It’s a comic scene, and on the face of it ridiculous, particularly directed at Mozart. But I kind of knew what that hapless lackey meant. There can be too much of a good thing, at least as I see it, a surplus of invention, particularly when it comes to writing mysteries.

Thus came my wonderment and annoyance about this novel. P. D. James’ ability to create involving, multi-dimensional characters and settings ultimately gets in the way of what a mystery should be about.

Thursday, February 1, 2018

Shroud For A Nightingale – P. D. James, 1971 ★★★½

Death Visits the Nurses's Wing

A mystery can be too good to properly enjoy when one of two things get in the way: 1) Getting too invested in one possible outcome to the point of resenting another the author goes with instead, or 2) Being so caught up that you race through the final pages and miss key details.


I think Shroud For A Nightingale might have been for me an example of the first. I definitely did not rush the ending, but it still caught me short. I found myself more interested in the red herrings than the final solution.

Saturday, September 27, 2014

Innocent Blood – P. D. James, 1980 ★★★★½

Blood Is Thicker

A departure from P. D. James' famous run of detective novels featuring Adam Dalgliesh, Innocent Blood is a stand-alone mystery less about crime than those who are its victims. It's a satisfying read, well-plotted and suspenseful, that raises unsettling questions about identity and love.